

Pizza in Menomonee Falls, WI 53051






I stumbled onto this place by accident. Had a bad experience one night with a pizza place next to Wing Stop on 124th & Capitol. I Googled "pizza near me" and Pizza Crafters popped up. I ordered online from the parking lot of not named pizza place and my order was ready as soon as I walked in! I spotted the salad bar around the corner and came back to try the buffet. Now we come here nearly every Sunday after church. This is also my new place to meet clients for lunch! The flavored water machines top off the experience 👌🏿






Ordered a pizza and had trouble with the delivery. Ended up picking the pizza up and received an order of brownies as an apology. Good customer service and the pizza was good too.






I stopped here today with my kids as it was close to where we were hiking. The kids and I definitely enjoyed it and would come back again if we were in the area. The pizza was as good or better than other pizza buffets we’ve gone to over the years. There was a good selection of pizzas, and they cooked up a pizza my daughter requested. They also had some tasty garlic cheese strips, and a salad area that I didn’t partake in so cannot comment on. The price was reasonable for the selection of food in my opinion.






My boyfriend and I tried Pizza Crafters for the first time yesterday and throughout the rest of the day, we kept saying we wish we had tried it sooner. We were the first customers of the day, so the owner asked us what pizzas we'd like them to make right away. We were shocked how fast they came out and they were SO good! The salad bar has everything you could want and I highly recommend the Garlic Chicken Pizza- it was amazing. They also have a great selection of bottled beer, which we weren't expecting. We will 110% be back!





























This place is absolutely incredible! An old school pizza buffet, very good (freshly made) pizza, a surprisingly good salad bar, and great desserts. You wouldn't expect a place like this to have food gluten free options but they absolutely do. It was very busy when I was there and their kitchen kept up, I don'tthink they ever ran out of any of the pizzas. Highly recommended