Delivery Area

See what our customers say

Jason Mattison
Jason Mattison
04/23/2024

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
My cousin and I went here for lunch today. The staff was really friendly and checked in with you to see how things were going along the way. Buffet style pizza and salad layout. Really liked the options. They do a good job. I'll be back.

Mary Beth Eilbes
Mary Beth Eilbes
03/04/2024

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Wasn't busy at all. Explained first time here. Cashier explained all the details. Was Ash Wednesday, so I needed a meatless meal. Cashier said "a veggie or a basil & mozzarella pizza". Then she asked if I wanted both so I didn't have to choose. Ate from the extensive salad buffet, where both hot/cold items are offered, along with cinnamon rolls & brownies, which I didn't try cause I was too full The salad buffet was plenty, but I really wanted pizza & could smell them baking. Within about 15 mins, both pizzas were on the buffet. Smelled as good as they tasted. Love the crust! I think this pizza would be good cold, or the next day reheated. They also have lots of pizza ideas on their menu, or make your own. Don't remember if drinks are included in the price. Cleared my own dirty dishes.

Jessica Garrett
Jessica Garrett
02/04/2024

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
I would definitely go back there. The food was awesome, the cheesy bread was amazing. Sure; it can get crowded but that’s because there is a lot of variety. I would rate 8 stars if I could. -T, 10 year old boy

Kelly Lee
Kelly Lee
01/28/2024

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Customer service was really nice. Lady at front register explained everything (1st timers) and the kid making the pizza was friendly and attentive. Nice to go somewhere that still offers actual Customer service.

Marcus Deneen
Marcus Deneen
01/06/2024

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
This is a great pizza buffet! The staff was nice and polite. This facility was clean and had a very peaceful atmosphere. The pizza was really good and we definitely will be back. I'm adding this location to my favorites on my phone. I recommend this place if you are looking for a good pizza buffet!

Brian
Brian
12/31/2023

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
My family and I had a great visit and enjoyed the variety of food. It reminded me of all the awesome pizza buffets when I was a kid. The staff and owner were friendly and helpful. Highly recommend!

Dawn Wayne
Dawn Wayne
12/29/2023

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
This was my first time here. I just love this place lots of pizzas to choose from, salads, dessert and fountain sodas,water. And the staff were so amazing and friendly. I will differently go back soon. Thanks guys.

A Google User
A Google User
12/29/2023

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
This was my first time here. I just love this place lots of pizzas to choose from, salads, dessert and fountain sodas,water. And the staff were so amazing and friendly. I will differently go back soon. Thanks guys.

dizroca
dizroca
12/14/2023

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Very clean. Always welcoming. Super veteran and military friendly. A way better version of Cici's. Foods great. Owner is awesome. Staff is courteous.

aaron lerose
aaron lerose
11/18/2023

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
This place is a gem. Some of the best pizza. Super fresh and fast. The buffet prices are insanely low. Quality+Wallet friendly=Happy freakin customer.

Alma
Alma
09/11/2023

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
My family and I go here often and its always really calm and comfortable. You can always ask for whatever you want if its not out on the buffet and its usually done within 10 minutes. The cheesy breadsticks are amazing! I’ll always keep coming back 🙂

Some guy
Some guy
07/12/2023

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Pizza Crafters reminded me of Tazino's in Oak Creek. Great spot for a get-together or just to go for the day.
The price was good. $14 dollars per person, with drinks and all you can eat buffet.

The food was good. I loved the specialty pizza. The BBQ Chicken Pizza was my favorite.

The service was great too! My family and I will definitely be back.

Drew Jefferson
Drew Jefferson
05/11/2023

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
I stumbled onto this place by accident. Had a bad experience one night with a pizza place next to Wing Stop on 124th & Capitol. I Googled "pizza near me" and Pizza Crafters popped up. I ordered online from the parking lot of not named pizza place and my order was ready as soon as I walked in! I spotted the salad bar around the corner and came back to try the buffet. Now we come here nearly every Sunday after church. This is also my new place to meet clients for lunch! The flavored water machines top off the experience 👌🏿

Ben Andersen
Ben Andersen
05/11/2023

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Ordered a pizza and had trouble with the delivery. Ended up picking the pizza up and received an order of brownies as an apology. Good customer service and the pizza was good too.

shawn thiele
shawn thiele
03/11/2023

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
I stopped here today with my kids as it was close to where we were hiking. The kids and I definitely enjoyed it and would come back again if we were in the area. The pizza was as good or better than other pizza buffets we’ve gone to over the years. There was a good selection of pizzas, and they cooked up a pizza my daughter requested. They also had some tasty garlic cheese strips, and a salad area that I didn’t partake in so cannot comment on. The price was reasonable for the selection of food in my opinion.

Jessica Neuhaus
Jessica Neuhaus
03/11/2023

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
My boyfriend and I tried Pizza Crafters for the first time yesterday and throughout the rest of the day, we kept saying we wish we had tried it sooner. We were the first customers of the day, so the owner asked us what pizzas we'd like them to make right away. We were shocked how fast they came out and they were SO good! The salad bar has everything you could want and I highly recommend the Garlic Chicken Pizza- it was amazing. They also have a great selection of bottled beer, which we weren't expecting. We will 110% be back!

John Carlino
John Carlino
11/11/2022

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
This place is absolutely incredible! An old school pizza buffet, very good (freshly made) pizza, a surprisingly good salad bar, and great desserts. You wouldn't expect a place like this to have food gluten free options but they absolutely do. It was very busy when I was there and their kitchen kept up, I don'tthink they ever ran out of any of the pizzas. Highly recommended

Jennifer Wiese
Jennifer Wiese
11/11/2022

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
This is a must stop location! We will definitely be back! We stopped with our small group of students after attending the MSO downtown! The staff reserved seats for us and made sure the buffet was hot and full! The students (and chaperones) raved! Looking forward to bringing my family!

Shalini khare
Shalini khare
10/11/2022

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
This is such an amazing buffet pizza place. Wonderful salad bar and variety of pizza options. Staff was friendly and food was delicious.Buffet is reasonably priced too. Vegetarian options: Vegetarian pizzas and salads available. Kid-friendliness: Kids friendly place , they have a chalkboard for kids to scribble and enjoy. Parking: Parking is available in the complex. Wheelchair accessibility: Restaurant is wheelchair accessible.

GMS Vasha
GMS Vasha
10/11/2022

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
The true test of a buffet is how their food is during the slow times. I walked in at about 13:45 on a Tuesday. I was promptly greeted and asked what kind of pizza I would like on the buffet. I asked if they make a margherita and they said sure we can get one in the oven in just a few minutes. They also threw in a fresh pepperoni and their current specialty pizza, a broccoli cheese. The margherita and all of the other pizzas were excellent. The store was clean and atmosphere pleasant. Another big plus was the nacho cheese they offer as an alternative to marinara for bread sticks. I highly recommend this establishment to any pizza lover and will be returning again soon.

Shalini khare
Shalini khare
10/09/2022

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
This is such an amazing buffet pizza place. Wonderful salad bar and variety of pizza options. Staff was friendly and food was delicious.Buffet is reasonably priced too.

Jenni Jex
Jenni Jex
09/11/2022

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
We enjoyed our family lunch here today. The place was clean and had a good selection of pizzas. I like that they have a specialty pizza of the week to add variety to their menu for returning customers. The salad bar was great! The kids also enjoyed the window where they could watch pizzas being made.

Dennis Valuch
Dennis Valuch
09/11/2022

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
A good value that's always tasty. If you ask, they will make your pizza to order. Lots of other good sides. This is a great place to take your family for a quick & fresh meal.

Brianna Vail
Brianna Vail
08/11/2022

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Really love the salad bar, it's hard to find a good salad bar these days! Stopped in for lunch and the owner was very kind. It was a little after 1pm so the buffet was a little limited, but we were offered to have any pizza made that we requested which really puts this place above others in the area. I will be moving down the road next month, and I'm excited to have this place near by. The CBR and the Tailgater pizza are by far my two favorites!

Austin Nerby
Austin Nerby
08/11/2022

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
The wife and i came here for the friday night dinner buffet. Came to be $12 per person and it was totally worth it. Some of the best pizza in the north milwaukee area! Must try there chicken bacon ranch pizza and there cheesy garlic bread! Its to die for! We will definitely be back!

Stephanie Waymaster
Stephanie Waymaster
07/11/2022

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Great Team Lunch while here at a tournament!

Michael Zore
Michael Zore
07/11/2022

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Superb pizza and salad bar, with an excellent mix of pizza selections that changes each time you come back for more. My favorite was the stuffed crust nacho, with a nice little bite to it, but the Supreme with a tasty mix of fresh ingredients gives it a good run for the #1 spot on my list. With all of these all-you-can-eat choices (and I haven't even mentioned the fabulously fresh selection of items for the salad I started with), you might be tempted to stuff yourself, but remember to save a couple bites for dessert: I'd happily spend a morning putting myself into a sugar coma with a pile of their cinnamon bites, if they ever open to serve these for breakfast! Great food for a good price.

Mike Fredricks
Mike Fredricks
07/11/2022

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Delicious! We placed a very large order for a party we were hosting and everything went perfect. Food was ready at our pick up time and nothing was missed. Great job and will definitely visit again!

Sean
Sean
07/11/2022

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
The lady at the front counter made me feel super welcome right off the bat! Very reasonable price for a delicious Buffet with all sorts of different items including a great salad bar pizza dessert and soda. Love this place, will be back !

Scott M
Scott M
07/11/2022

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Very nice clean place for a pizza buffet. Staff was very nice and food was very fresh. Self-serve soda with free refills and an all-around clean place. Would definitely go back again.

Keith Heins
Keith Heins
07/11/2022

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Love this place. I met the owner at my place of work. Tim was buying fresh produce for Pizza Crafters. My first visit was fantastic as every item was so fresh and tasty!! One of my go to places now!

Shad Garvey
Shad Garvey
07/11/2022

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Good pizza, lots of different choices. Hard to find a salad bar anymore, but they do it well. Plenty of seating. Who can turn down a pizza/salad buffet?

Ted Schaar
Ted Schaar
07/11/2022

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Stopped in yesterday for the first time. Great salad bar and out-of-sight pizza! Everything was spanking clean and the help was friendly and attentive. Hope to return soon.

Peter Sayarath
Peter Sayarath
07/11/2021

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
We were looking for a family friendly restaurant with a fair price. The Pizza Crafters was the perfect choice. Their salad was great. The variety of pizza with Mac and Cheese satisfied the toddlers. The Buffalo Chicken Pizza has the right amount of sauce. The dessert brownie didn't look appealing... To our surprise it was perfect.

Vaibhav Chhabra
Vaibhav Chhabra
07/11/2021

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Decided to give this restaurant a try after seeing great reviews on Google. Tried their veg pizza options. They had right amount of cheese, loaded with veggies, and ingredients were fresh. Taste is delicious. Will definitely try their other options. Well maintained and very hygienic environment. Definitely deserve 5 star. They should add some vegan pizzas to the menu.

Jenni Wuehr
Jenni Wuehr
07/11/2021

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Just moved to the area, we visit a different pizza buffet regularly but we decided to try pizza crafters out! I am so glad we did! We were greeted by the owner who was very friendly and explained how everything worked. We walked back to the buffet and everyone greeted us with a friendly hello! The food was hot and fresh and any requests made were delivered very quickly! The ingredients they use were fresh, and unprocessed! The restaurant was very clean and kept. We will definitely be back!

Douglas H
Douglas H
07/11/2021

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Always clean and has friendly staff. During the time we went it was rather slow. Employees were busy cleaning and making to go orders. Tim the owner was there and offered to make us fresh pizzas of our choice for the buffet. Started with salads and the girl that made the salads due to covid restrictions had no problem making our very detailed toppings on the salads. Always had a smile and was very polite. The pizzas were good. But honestly Tim, seemed a little undercooked. Still good but have had better there before. Won't detour me from coming back,but just thought you should know. Thanks to your staff for an always welcoming experience 😊

Nicole R
Nicole R
07/11/2021

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
Fresh ingredients, clean spaces, friendly staff. Went with a group of 10 and had no problems getting food, drinks, and seating for all. Salad bar was awesome. Kids loved the Mac and cheese pizza. Used Groupon and saved a few dollars, which is always awesome.

pip blank
pip blank
07/11/2021

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Really pleased with out decision to eat here. The food was good and the staff was extremely friendly. They have switched from open buffet style to lunch room cafeteria style and it works well. Everything feels very safe and clean. They have many different pizza options and there is also some pasta and a salad bar.

Bhuvaneswari Muralitharan
Bhuvaneswari Muralitharan
07/11/2020

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Excellent food at a very good price. Very friendly and polite staff members, very friendly atmosphere to go and we enjoy the food with family, very cheesy yummy varieties of pizzas to choose on their buffet, excellent brownie dessert. Loved the place. They were refilling continuously.

Kelly Pearse
Kelly Pearse
07/11/2020

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Excellent pizza options that are always being freshly made and swapped out when one goes empty. They offer a weekly stuffer that is always a nicely added touch to their main options. They have a great salad bar that is loaded with tons of options. For the amount of options they have the price is beyond reasonable. The staff is always super friendly.

Pizza in Menomonee Falls

53051

Pizza Crafters BBB Business Review